NewsU.S. and the WorldScripps News

Actions

After Ohio approves abortion rights, Republicans vow to continue fight

Ohioans voted to protect and legalize abortion access Tuesday, but Republicans say the fight is not over.
After Ohio approves abortion rights, Republicans vow to continue fight
Posted at 10:24 AM, Nov 10, 2023
and last updated 2023-11-10 12:24:36-05

Ohioans voted to protect and legalize abortion access Tuesday, but the fight is not over.

In a 13-point victory, Issue 1 passed.

"This is a huge win," said Veronica Ingham with Ohioans United for Reproductive Rights. "We must continue to fight for freedom and defend democracy."

The constitutional amendment to allow abortions until fetal viability, generally 21-22 weeks, would override an Ohio law that says abortions cannot be performed after about six weeks.

Even though the constitutional amendment will go into effect in early December, all of the restrictions up until now must be settled and dealt with in court.

"All of those things are going to get litigated in the courts as the government proposes rules and plaintiffs attack those rules as being overly restrictive," Case Western Reserve University law professor Atiba Ellis said.

There are restrictions currently being evaluated by the Ohio Supreme Court, like the six-week ban.

Despite their decisive loss, Statehouse Republicans and anti-abortion groups have plans to stop Issue 1.

One idea is fighting to keep the most stringent restrictions they can under the amendment, according to House Speaker Jason Stephens.

"The legislature has multiple paths that we will explore to continue to protect innocent life," Stephens said. "This is not the end of the conversation.”

End Abortion Ohio's Austin Beigel is on board with that.

"There are processes through our system of government that can change things around," he said.

SEE MORE: Election night recap: Abortion rights, marijuana, incumbents win

His idea would be to use the 14th Amendment in the US Constitution to rule that the state constitution is now in violation of the equal protection clause. This is often called the "personhood" argument.

"I don't think it's a very good argument," nonpartisan CWRU law professor Entin said. "I think that there has been a virtually universal understanding among lawyers and judges that when the Constitution talks about people or persons, we're talking about folks who are born."

Beigel begs to differ, and said he is working with lawmakers on possibly proposing legislation to support this idea. 

The other main GOP plan is putting forward another amendment to repeal Issue 1, which comes from Senate President Matt Huffman.

"This isn't the end," Huffman said. "It is really just the beginning of a revolving door of ballot campaigns to repeal or replace Issue 1."

Both law professors, Ingham and Beigel, all believe this isn't a good idea.

"I don't think that the pure democratic process works for the abortion issue right now if you're against abortion," Beigel said.

Secretary of State Frank LaRose and many of the Republican lawmakers pushed for the controversial August Issue 1, which would have made it more difficult for the abortion amendment to pass in November. This strategic attempt to thwart the will of the people was shot down in a bipartisan fashion. The Republicans then tried everything they could to stop people from supporting November's Issue 1. If they put up another amendment to try to stop abortion, the voters will "lose their minds," according to an Issue 1 victory party-goer.

However, Entin explained that there is a way the Republicans could get a win. The conservative Ohio Supreme Court justices can read the six-week ban and interpret it however they want — possibly putting it back into effect — but that would be a huge and unlikely stretch.

"I have a really hard time believing that the justices would be willing to just bend the language to that extent," he said. "I could envision anti-abortion justices in a case involving the Heartbeat Law saying, 'We think this is a terrible outcome, but the language of the Ohio Constitution means that we have to strike down this law.'"

SEE MORE: Abortion votes are causing a divide on state ballots across the US

There have been 31 abortion restrictions passed since 2011 in Ohio, according to Ohioans United for Reproductive Rights.

However, Democrats can propose legislation that would eliminate all of the restrictions — and they plan to do so. It is significantly more likely that this will be dealt with in court, considering the GOP has a supermajority and it would be shocking to see them pass protections for abortion.

Twenty-seven of 67 Republican members of the House have condemned the passage of Issue 1.

This story was originally published by Morgan Trau for Scripps News Cleveland.


Trending stories at Scrippsnews.com